Welcome to Gilligan's Island
Gilligan's Island is a charming eatery located at 64 N Main St in Sherburne, NY, celebrated for its inviting atmosphere and friendly service. Customers rave about their hearty burgers, crispy onion rings, and indulgent soft serve, with standout items like the Gilligan’s burger and rich milkshakes that leave a lasting impression. The restaurant's cleanliness and pet-friendly gesture—offering dog biscuits—further enhance the experience. Whether you're meeting friends for lunch or enjoying a sweet treat, Gilligan's Island promises satisfying meals that keep diners returning for more. A must-stop for anyone passing through Sherburne.
Gilligan's Island: Reviews & Ratings
Met some Army buddies here for lunch and we were all very impressed. Nice size burgers, huge onion rings. Very friendly staff. Not to mention it seems like the only place in town you can sit down and eat that's open on Monday and Tuesday. Very impressed.
We have been getting soft serve from the takeout window for years, I’ve been wanting to try a burger and fries. Today I finally did it. I ordered a Gilligan’s burger, large fries and a large vanilla malted shake. Tons of food! Hot and crispy fries, a shake that barely came through the straw, and the burger was well dressed with crispy bacon. All in for 20. The place is clean. The staff is super nice, and if they see your pups in the car, there are dog biscuits too! Highly recommend this place and I will be working my way through the menu as we travel through Sherberne.
I always hit this place up when I come back to NY to visit family. My dad is a frequent flyer here for the milkshakes alone. But everything I've had there has been delicious
I had a large dark chocolate with almonds ice cream cone. It was huge. More like a meal than a snack. I guess people usually get the small one. Very tasty, creamy homemade ice cream. Restaurant interior is very nice, exterior could be spruced up a little bit.
Oh Gilligan's, how do we love thee? Let us count the ways! Great burgers, great o-rings, great fries, great service and BEST ice cream! If you drive through Sherburne and don't stop here, it better be because you're going to your mom's for lunch. On second thought, take that woman some ice cream! She'll love you for it.
I bought a medium twist. This thing was HUGE, delicious and only cost 3.78! I recently bought a "medium" twist from an Oneida ice cream parlor and it was 5, she gave me the wrong flavor, and it was the size of a baby cone! Literally 3 licks and it was gone! I will definitely be frequenting Gilligans many times this summer!
We stopped for ice cream while passing through. It was very busy, but it moved along quickly. I tried the fruity pebble and Irish cream soft serve. It was amazing. They also have a food menu.
I have bought you ice cream from Farm to Table in Greene NY . Very impressed. Wonderful flavor. Very creamy I’m on container number 3
Location
-
64 N Main St, Sherburne, NY 13460, United States Hotline: +1 607-674-4397
Welcome to Gilligan's Island, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Sherburne, NY. Located at 64 N Main St, this establishment stands out not just for its vibrant atmosphere but also for its remarkable offerings that leave a lasting impression on locals and visitors alike.
Catering to a variety of appetites, Gilligan's Island is a must-visit for anyone in search of hearty meals. The reviews speak volumes about the sheer size and quality of their menu items—especially the burgers. One customer, Matthew Roche, remarked on the impressive size of these burgers along with the oversized onion rings that complement them perfectly. It's a place where friends gather to enjoy good food and good company, making it an ideal stop for lunch meetings or family outings.
Soft serve enthusiasts will also find a delight at Gilligan's Island. Todd Vincent's experience with their signature Gilligan’s burger, crispy fries, and thick malted shake reinforces the idea that this is a spot where you won't leave hungry. The dedication to food quality shines through—hot, crispy fries and a burger generously topped with bacon underscore their commitment to deliciousness.
Beyond just the dining experience, Gilligan’s Island offers a touch of warmth. The friendly staff is often mentioned in reviews, ensuring that every visit feels personal. Erin Belden, a returning customer, emphasizes how her father makes it a habit to stop by for their milkshakes—a testament to the addictive nature of their creamy, homemade ice cream. You might even find treats for your four-legged friends, as they often provide dog biscuits for pups waiting patiently in cars.
For those with a sweet tooth, Samanthi Martinez enthusiastically claims Gilligan's serves the best ice cream in town. Her passion resonates with me, as I can't help but savor the thought of indulging in their flavorful ice cream cones—an experience more substantial than merely a snack.
In a quaint locale where dining options can be limited, Gilligan's Island shines brightly as a reliable choice, particularly open on Monday and Tuesday when many other eateries remain closed. The inviting ambiance encapsulated by its clean interiors—and a slightly more rugged exterior—gives it a character that is as warm as the food itself. In essence, if you're traversing through Sherburne and skip this culinary destination, you just might regret it.
So, the next time you're in town, treat yourself to the burgers, the fries, the shakes, and the extraordinary service at Gilligan's Island. Your taste buds will thank you!